The Results Are in! Reader Feedback and Author Insights

Happy January, readers! I hope you had a blessed Christmas!

What’s in this Edition:

  • Meet the Author – Get to know Kelsey Gietl
  • The Results are In! – Learn how you’re making my books better
  • Writing Update – The latest on Astonished
  • Recent Reads I Recommend – My favorite reads from last month.
  • A Little Non-Bookish Delight – My beautiful new Last Supper painting

Get to know Kelsey Gietl

Happy New Year! There were many new subscribers in 2025 (welcome again!), so it’s time to do another “Meet the Author.” Here are just a few facts about me. What else would you like to know?

The Results are In!

Photo by Daniel Schludi on Unsplash

Thank you to everyone who participated in the 2025 Reader Preferences Survey! With so many options available to readers, it’s important to pinpoint what brings you back to my individual stories and newsletter time and again. I appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts. Here are the highlights:

General Information:

  • Top reasons for choosing a book – being recommended by a friend, an intriguing description and/or title, eye-catching cover art, no explicit sexual content, minimal profanity, and including Christian themes. Surprisingly, price was one of the least considered factors.
  • Top Read Genres – Historical Fiction/Historical Romance, Contemporary Romance, and Mystery/Suspense.
  • Most readers (73.9%) prefer series novels to standalone with 43.5% preferring a connected series (all books read in order).
  • 57% of readers prefer reading physical books over ebooks.
  • Top book-specific sites – Goodreads (70%), BookBub, JustRead Tours, and NetGalley.

Pricing:

  • Readers’ preferred price points remain at $14.99 for paperbacks and $4.99 for ebooks.
  • Over 70% of readers are not part of an ebook subscription plan. 26% use Kindle Unlimited.
  • Most readers (82.6%) have not purchased a book from my online store. Most of you said you would like to support authors directly, but ultimately choose sites with free shipping. (I completely understand this. I wish I could offer free shipping without raising product cost.)
  • Related to the possibility of a book box offering, interest was pretty evenly split. I’m going to give this more thought.

Email Newsletter:

  • Almost all of you (98%) continue to prefer the current frequency of 2x per month at the current length.
  • Top 5 Topics Read – Get to Know the Author, Sales/Giveaways, Background of my Books, Writing Updates, and Recommendations.
  • Most of you (78%) preferred to know what I’m personally reading over any other kind of recommendation. 90% combined were also interested in monthly new releases and author interviews/giveaways. Going forward, my personal recommendations will be in the main newsletter with other authors’ new releases in the Extra Edition newsletter. Interviews/giveaways will be intermittent.

While the survey timeframe has ended, feedback is always appreciated. Please send any questions or comments as a reply to this email or via my contact page.

Writing Update

Good news! I’m about halfway done drafting Astonished and have made good progress on the remaining half. These characters are taking me for a wild ride, but don’t they always? Speaking of demanding characters, the book I’m planning for after Astonished also barged its way in and demanded some of my time. I’ve got a decent start on an outline with one of Astonished‘s side characters returning as the lead.

For those of you who have read my Over the Atlantic and/or War Across Waters series, I hope you’ll be pleased with the character cameo scene I just finished writing for Astonished. I was really happy to have an excuse to bring back one of my favorite British journalists. Any guesses who it is?

New to the newsletter? Learn more about Astonished.

Recent Reads I Recommend

Need another book for your TBR? Of course you do. Here are the books I’ve recently read and loved. (Note: I receive no compensation for featuring the books below.)

“Death is not a period – it’s a comma. A breath, a waiting, a symbol of more to come. God’s work continues.” Christy-Award-finalist The Way Back by Heidi Chiavoroli is a dual-timeline story deep in complicated family dynamics, overcoming trauma and grief, and discovering the power of forgiveness and moving forward…all with God’s help. These characters were richly portrayed and deeply relatable. We may not all have experienced exactly what they did, but their emotions are universal to the human experience. Just like death, what we go through in life only stops us from living if we leave God out of the equation. With Him, all of life’s challenges are just commas, not the end of the sentence. This was my first Heidi Chiavoroli book and won’t be the last.

While I’ve read and enjoyed all of Hannah Hood Lucero’s books, Battle Charged was my favorite to date. Set in Colorado, there are many twists and turns to this military romantic suspense with the constant question of which characters can be trusted. In the author’s notes, Hannah says this book was the hardest for her to connect with, but to me, it reads with a lot of vulnerability and heart. Plus, it’s a standalone so it makes the perfect book to start with if you’re new to Hannah’s work.

(Note: While I was paid to design the cover for this book, I was not required to leave a positive review or feature in any way.)

Did you know reviews help both readers and authors? Even one sentence is enough, and every word greatly appreciated. Consider leaving a rating on Amazon, Goodreads, BookBub, and/or your favorite retailer!

Want to know what I’m reading as I’m reading it? Follow me on GoodReads.

A Little Non-Bookish Delight

Last but not least, here’s something non-bookish that I’m loving. Last week, my family added curtains to our kitchen transom window which left the wall beneath feeling too bare. Cue a trip to Hobby Lobby. My daughter and I found a beautiful painting of the Last Supper that fits the space perfectly, although the photo doesn’t do the colors justice. What I like most is that it breaks from the usual mold of DaVinci’s Last Supper while still remaining reverent. This now hangs right behind our kitchen table, a constant reminder of the meal we share in the Eucharist at Mass.



Purchase signed copies of my books: kelseygietl.com

Follow me on:
1454549143-1454549143_goodreads_misc
BB 96x96 S
COPYRIGHT © KELSEY GIETL 2026

Purple Mask Publishing

2025 Zumbehl Rd, Ste. 33

St. Charles, MO 63303

Top Must-Read Books of 2025

2025 was a great year for reading! I finished 77 books with many wonderful 4 and 5 star selections. As the year comes to a close, here are my Top 10 recommended reads, listed first by genre, then by author’s last name. Have you read any of these? Which books should I add to my must-read list in 2026?

(Note: I receive no compensation for featuring the books below.)

This year, my reading list was light on Historical Fiction (surprising I know), so it was pretty easy to choose my Top 10. Historical Fantasy and Time Travel are included in the Speculative category below.

Tri-Timeline: Splinters and Seams by Courtney Rivera, Dual Timeline 1920s/1960s: The Bootlegger’s Betrayal by Tanya E. Williams, Protestant Reformation: Secret Dwellings by Angelina Salvaggio (1st in series), American Revolution: Perpetual Rainbows by Jessika Caruso (1st in series), American Frontier: On the Banks of Plum Creek by Laura Ingalls Wilder, 1830s: Some Melodious Sonnet by Jennifer Q. Hunt (1st in series), 1850s: The Bachelor and the Bride by Sarah Eden (4th in series, but I read as a standalone), 1910s: Hope Like Wildflowers by Pepper Basham (3rd in series, but I read as a standalone), 1920s: Whispers of Her Worth by Tanya E. Williams, World War II: The Girls of the Glimmer Factory by Jennifer Coburn (2nd in series, Note for clean readers: There is one open door sex scene.),

I read way more Contemporary Fiction this year, so narrowing the choices was more difficult. These are mostly romances with a few exceptions, such as The Fire of Your Love which is centered around religious vocations.

Between the Sound and Sea by Amanda Cox, For Eden’s Sake by T.M. Gaouette, The Crafted With Love series by Maddie Evans (Book 3 was my favorite, but the entire series was great), The Dating Charade by Melissa Ferguson, Summer Ever After by Kortney Keisel, The Fire of Your Love by Erin Lewis (3rd in series, I recommend reading in order), A Name to Remember by Hannah Hood Lucero, Emma’s Hero by Carrie Walker (1st in series)

I’m smashing all these genres together as I didn’t have enough in any one for a Top 10.

Paranormal: The Curse He Chose by Sr. Allison Regina Gliot (1st in series, I don’t usually enjoy paranormal, but I’ve already pre-ordered book 2), Time Travel: Braving Strange Waters by Sarah Hanks (1st in series), In this Moment and For a Lifetime by Gabrielle Meyer (2nd and 3rd in series), Dystopian: Scythe by Neal Shusterman (1st in series), Historical Fantasy Re-reads: Sorcerous & Treacherous by Susan Laspe (1st & 2nd in series), Afterlife Fiction (because I don’t know what to call it): A Hiker’s Guide to Purgatory by Michael Norton, The Historical Fiction/Dystopian/Magical realism/Romance series I didn’t know I wanted to binge read and then loved: The Land Uncharted series by Keely Brooke Keith (15-book series, I never start a series this long, but it was well worth it. Book 1 & 15 are pictured. Book 16 coming soon.)

I have to give an extra special shout-out to my fellow Catholic Christian authors. My Catholic reads were extremely varied this year from historical to fantasy to contemporary to paranormal with all but two being new to me authors.

Historical Fiction: Perpetual Rainbows by Jessika Caruso (1st in series), Secret Dwellings by Angelina Salvaggio (1st in series), Contemporary Romance: The Crafted with Love series by Maddie Evans, Pro-Life Romance: For Eden’s Sake by T.M. Gaouette, Emma’s Hero by Carrie Walker (1st in series), Paranormal: The Curse He Chose by Sr. Allison Regina Gliot (1st in series), Historical Fantasy Re-read: Sorcerous by Susan Laspe (1st in series), Religious Vocations Fiction: The Fire of Your Love by Erin Lewis (3rd in series, I recommend reading in order), Afterlife Fiction (because I still don’t know what to call it): A Hiker’s Guide to Purgatory by Michael Norton, Non-Fiction: Near Death Experiences by Scott L. Smith, Jr.

Want to read my full reviews? Follow me on GoodReads.

Did you know reviews help both readers and authors? Even one sentence is enough, and every word greatly appreciated. Consider leaving a rating on Amazon, Goodreads, BookBub, and/or your favorite retailer!


Until next time, happy reading!
Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam
Kelsey

Purchase signed copies of my books: kelseygietl.com

Follow me on:
1454549143-1454549143_goodreads_misc
BB 96x96 S
COPYRIGHT © KELSEY GIETL 2025

Purple Mask Publishing

2025 Zumbehl Rd, Ste. 33

St. Charles, MO 63303

2 Days Left: Make your voice heard in the Reader Preferences Survey

Welcome back to the Extra Edition newsletter! December’s crazy busy so this edition has one request and a reminder. I hope you all have a Merry Christmas!

***A Quick Request*** – I received a comment from the Reader Preferences Survey asking, “I know very few Catholic authors and would love to know more! Can you email me if you know more?” The survey didn’t collect names or email addresses, so if this was you, please reply to this newsletter. I would love to talk more!

***Reminder!*** – My 2025 Reader Preferences Survey is still open until this Wednesday, December 17. With so many options available to readers, it’s important to pinpoint what brings you back to my individual stories and newsletter time and again. I would greatly appreciate it if you could take ten minutes of your time to complete the survey below. All the questions are optional, but I do hope you will consider completing them. Responses are anonymous, so please share all your thoughts! Thank you to all those who have already responded!

Provide Your Reader Preferences


Until next time, happy reading!
Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam
Kelsey

Purchase signed copies of my books: kelseygietl.com

Follow me on:
1454549143-1454549143_goodreads_misc
BB 96x96 S
COPYRIGHT © KELSEY GIETL 2025

Purple Mask Publishing

2025 Zumbehl Rd, Ste. 33

St. Charles, MO 63303

The Good, the Bad, and the So-so: Share Your Thoughts in the 2025 Reader Preferences Survey

Happy December, readers, and welcome to new subscribers from the O’Fallon Holiday Market and Francis Howell Craft Fair! Between family and church events, my day job, designing covers, and completing my Missionaries of Joy classes, there hasn’t been a lot of time for writing lately. But don’t worry; I’m still making progress on Astonished. Slow and steady wins the race!

What’s in this Edition:

  • 2025 Reader Preferences Survey – Let me know what you want to see!
  • Events! – Photos from 3 Recent Events
  • Christmas Gift Guide – Gifts from the Catholic Marketing Network
  • Releasing in December– Other authors’ new releases I’m most excited about

Reader Preference Survey

By Timothy Eberly on Unsplash

My last reader preference survey was in August 2022, over three years ago, which means it is past time for an update. (How does time always get away from us?) With so many options available to readers, it’s important to pinpoint what brings you back to my individual stories time and again. Obviously, you each signed up for this newsletter for a specific reason and there are reasons you continue with me month after month. There are reasons why you buy a book and reasons why you don’t. I want to know all those little details that help bring an ideal experience to my readers.

I would greatly appreciate it if you could take ten minutes of your time to complete the survey below. All the questions are optional, but I do hope you will consider completing them. Responses are anonymous, so please share all your thoughts! Thank you in advance! Survey closes on December 17.

Provide Your Reader Preferences

Events!

On November 8, I attended my first JustRead Rendezvous, an event that brings Christian authors and readers together for laidback discussion, community building, and of course, lots and lots of books! This year, the event was held in my own hometown of St. Louis which means I didn’t have to journey far to spend the day with over 150 other people who love Christian Fiction just as much as I do. The best part of the event was meeting bloggers I’ve only talked to online, talking to both familiar and new authors (yes, authors can still geek out about meeting other authors), and meeting readers who would literally chat all day about books. Seriously, so many free books. Out of this pile shown, I only ended up buying two of them. I’ve already finished Christy Award winner, Between the Sound and the Sea by Amanda Cox (5 stars!). Which one do you think I should read next?

On November 19, O’Fallon, Missouri had their Tree Lighting Ceremony which included a Holiday Market. Fellow author, Susan Laspe and I sold our books wearing festive hats within a corridor that doubled as an art gallery. The current exhibit showcased paintings by local author, Hannah Smith, including the one behind me in the photo above. I don’t know Hannah personally, but her acrylic paint and permanent marker art was a beautiful way to spend an evening. Here are a few of my favorite pieces linked from her site on Best of Missouri Hands.

Prickly Pear by Hannah Smith
Raspberry Vines by Hannah Smith

Finally, to finish out 2025’s events, Susan Laspe and I had a table at Francis Howell High School’s Craft Fair on December 6. There was a huge crowd at this one with lots of opportunities to chat about books and even take photos with readers. Thank you to everyone who came out to all three of these events. We look forward to seeing you at next year’s events!

Christmas Gift Guide

Still looking for Christmas gift ideas? Check out the Catholic Marketing Network’s 2025 Christmas Magazine. My books are listed on page 13 along with many other Christian books and gifts.

See the 2025 Christmas Catalog.

Releasing in December

Need another read? Here are the new releases I’m excited about:

  1. Every Voice Heard by N.Y. Dunlap, Sarah Hanks, & D.T. Powell – The third novella collection from the Brave Authors group focused on stories of overcoming church hurt and abuse
  2. Waking Courage by Madisyn Carlin, Samantha Seidel, & Courtney Ranger – A collection of fantasy fairy tale retellings
  3. My Fair Frauds by Lee Kelly & Jennifer Thorne – A high society fraud and a scrappy swindler team up to take down Gilded Age New York in a tale of intrigue, drama, and female friendship.
  4. The Relationship Remodel by Callie Thomas – Opposites attract during a cross-country RV roadtrip romance
  5. Perfectly Complicated Christmas Romance by Grace Worthington – A closed-door holiday hockey romcom, featuring a grumpy athlete with a soft heart, a sunshine single mom, and a bet that proves opposites don’t just attract—they make a perfect mistletoe match.

Want to know what I’m currently reading? Follow me on GoodReads.

Did you know reviews help both readers and authors? Even one sentence is enough, and every word greatly appreciated. Consider leaving a rating on Amazon, Goodreads, BookBub, and/or your favorite retailer!


Until next month, happy reading!
Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam
Kelsey

Purchase signed copies of my books: kelseygietl.com

Follow me on:
1454549143-1454549143_goodreads_misc
BB 96x96 S
COPYRIGHT © KELSEY GIETL 2025

Purple Mask Publishing

2025 Zumbehl Rd, Ste. 33

St. Charles, MO 63303

The One Movie You Need to Watch

Welcome back to the Extra Edition newsletter! I’m excited to bring you bonus content each month with a special inside look at my novels and the history behind them.

What’s in this Edition:

Priests Who Paint – The real-life priest who inspired my fictional one

Triumph of the Heart – The one movie you need to watch

Priests Who Paint – Blessed Fra Angelico

The Crucifixion with Saints via Wikimedia Commons

In my next book, Astonished, you’ll meet the fictional Father Angelico. While his name was originally chosen because Blessed Fra Angelico is one of the patron saints of my daughter’s school, his back story is actually pretty cool. Fra Angelico, or Fra Giovanni da Fiesole (1395-1455) was an Italian Dominican friar and known as the Angelic Painter of the Renaissance. He started out illustrating manuscripts and choir books and eventually moved on to painting interiors of convents, churches, and other religious buildings. This included commissions from both Pope Eugenius IV and Pope Nicholas.

Fra Angelico was beatified (the last step before sainthood) by Pope St. John Paul II in 1982 and made the patron saint of artists in 1984. When the Pope was asked which miracles were attributed to the beatification, he pointed at Fra Angelico’s artwork and said, “These are his miracles.”

The Annunciation by Fra Angelico via Wikimedia Commons

What started out as just a character’s name in my book has now begun to transform the character himself. After learning about Fra Angelico’s work, I’ve given my fictional Father Angelico more of an artistic background himself. He may even play a role in future books; who knows?

Fra Angelico’s painting of The Last Judgment (shown below) has special meaning for by book, Astonished, as much of the story involves a woman with a near-death experience. This painting shows Christ at the center surrounded by angels and saints with heaven on his right and hell on his left.

The Last Judgment by Fra Angelico, via Wikimedia Commons

Triumph of the Heart: The one movie you need to watch

I recently had the opportunity to attend a screening of the new movie, Triumph of the Heart, about St. Maximilian Kolbe’s heroic decision to take the place of a man sentenced to a starvation bunker at Auschwitz. While this movie isn’t related to my books, it is an inspiring story for people of all faiths or no faith at all.

Simply put, this was one of the best movies I’ve ever seen. It made me think about our choices in life and how we relate to others, even when they don’t share our beliefs. In the bunker with Maximilian Kolbe were nine other men, all randomly chosen to die because another prisoner from their area had escaped. While no one knows the full backgrounds of these men, the movie does an excellent job of creating characters who represent a diverse range of professional and religious backgrounds. Within their interactions over their 14 days without food or water (yes, 14), these men show the darkest parts of humanity, but also that the beauty of human dignity, compassion, and faith cannot be defeated. It is a hard movie to watch and yet, one essential to the times we’re living in where martyrdom is still a regular occurrence yet rarely discussed.

I won’t give an age recommendation as parents know their children best. Although there is some violence, it is not gratuitous and is certainly tamer than many PG-13 movies I’ve seen. My husband and I took our middle schooler and high schooler to see it and it led to some wonderful discussions.

Triumph of the Heart is available to stream on their website: https://www.triumphoftheheart.com/streaming

Also, check out Cimorelli’s song, The Race is Run, which was written for the movie’s closing credits.


Until next time, happy reading!
Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam
Kelsey

Purchase signed copies of my books: kelseygietl.com

Follow me on:
1454549143-1454549143_goodreads_misc
BB 96x96 S
COPYRIGHT © KELSEY GIETL 2025

Purple Mask Publishing

2025 Zumbehl Rd, Ste. 33

St. Charles, MO 63303

Kelsey Gietl - Author

Historical Fiction with a Dose of Romance and a Dash of Intrigue

Skip to content ↓